The Villagers were from Dayton, possibly students at Carroll HS. They recorded a 45 that was released through Counterpart records although it uses a one off label name, Hamlet.
The band members were Janis Miles (the singer), Brian Blacker, Mike Copp, Bob Fowle, and Mike Wendling. Miles and Copp are the writers credited on the 45.
He's Not The Same / Sunshine My Way - Hamlet 1000, 1968